Our city isn’t just charming and historic — it’s also home to some of the best restaurants in Cape May, New Jersey. The historic charm, oceanfront views, and incredible food scene make Cape May a place visitors love to return to again and again. Craving an unforgettable dining experience? This list highlights seven must-visit spots, from laid-back bites to elegant fine dining. Each serves flavors as spectacular as the views.

The Mad Batter Restaurant

One of our favorite Cape May eateries is the Mad Batter Restaurant. It’s a Cape May classic you’ll want to check out yourself. It’s also a must-visit for anyone who enjoys delicious food in a lively, welcoming atmosphere.

The Mad Batter restaurant is right inside our historic Carroll Villa Hotel. It whips up award-winning breakfasts, creative lunches, and elevated dinners your taste buds will love. Ready to kickstart your day? Start with its legendary pancakes. Return later and unwind for dinner with seafood pasta and a cocktail while enjoying live music. It’s a win-win, either way.

The Cricket Club

The Cricket Club is a newer addition to Cape May’s dining scene. It’s also a sister restaurant to Mad Batter. The Cricket Club blends classic and modern flavors for something new, trendy, and exciting for your taste buds. This place is chic and upscale, so you’ll dine comfortably in the lounge-style dining room. Like Mad Batter, The Cricket Club offers live music and an impressive cocktail menu. But the food? Absolutely mouth-watering. Guests rave about the elevated comfort food, fresh seafood, and inventive small plates.

Grana BYOB

Grana BYOB is the perfect spot for bold dishes and fresh flavors with a contemporary American twist! Looking for something new? You’ve found it at Grana BYOB. This place changes its menu seasonally, so your taste buds always have something new to explore. Plus, it’s BYOB — so grab your favorite bottle of wine and make it a night to remember!

The Ebbitt Room

The Ebbitt Room stands out for fine dining and a farm-to-table experience. It’s inside the Virginia Hotel and offers a menu filled with beautifully prepared dishes. Many of its dishes feature ingredients from Beach Plum Farm. Every dish, from seared scallops to juicy steaks, is made with care. And if you love a handcrafted cocktail, their bar program is just as impressive as their cuisine.

Maison Bleue Bistro

A little taste of France in Cape May? Oui, please! Indulge in French-inspired favorites in a relaxed setting at Maison Bleue Bistro. Creme Brulee. Truffle Frites. Cassoulet. Perfectly cooked seafood? You’ll find it all here, all made fresh with local ingredients.

Primal

Are you a steak lover? If you’re nodding, head to Primal for something worth sinking your teeth into. You’ll find this spot a dream come true for your carnivore palate. We’re talking barrel-cut ribeye, porterhouse, lobster tail, mahi, and so much more. This beachfront steakhouse serves up premium cuts, grilled to perfection over an open flame — because great steak deserves a great view! The flavors are so tender and mouth-watering that it’s a shame that ‘smell-o-blog’ hasn’t been invented yet.

Locals and visitors love this restaurant’s rustic yet modern vibe. It sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. Reservations are recommended, especially during summer weekends.

Good Earth Organic Eatery

Love fresh, healthy, and organic eats? Good Earth Organic Eatery is the place to be! They whip up delicious dishes with locally sourced, organic ingredients — and you’ll find plenty of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options to love. So, it’s an excellent choice for those with dietary preferences — or anyone who appreciates fresh, flavorful food. Its homemade soups and farm-fresh salads are especially popular.

Other Things to Do in Cape May

While a foodie trip was at the top of this list, no trip exists on food alone. That said, there are plenty of other things to fill your days during your Cape May getaway. History, culture, and breathtaking coastal views fill our city. After indulging in some of the best restaurants, consider exploring these must-visit attractions:

View the Painted Ladies: These iconic Victorian homes add allure and character to Cape May’s historic district. Plus, they’re stunning — all decked out in bright pastels.
Visit the Emlen Physick Estate: Are you a history buff? Step back in time at this beautifully preserved 19th-century mansion.
Relax at Cape May Beach: Stunning shoreline. Soft sands. Beautiful ocean views — need we say more?
Climb the Cape May Lighthouse: The breathtaking panoramic view from the top is well worth the climb, so bring your camera.
Explore Cape May State Park: A perfect spot for nature lovers. Lots of scenic trails to explore. And it’s a birdwatcher’s paradise.
Have a Wine of a Time: Cape May has fantastic wineries where you can sip and savor local flavors.
Enjoy Live Jazz: The local jazz scene is thriving. Plenty of spots have great music and a laid-back vibe.

Savor the Best of Cape May’s Dining Scene

Cape May’s food scene is as rich in history as in flavor. Craving a casual beachfront meal? Planning a romantic getaway or a girl’s trip — or maybe you’re looking for a few date night ideas? Want a gourmet farm-to-table experience? You’ll find it all here in Cape May. The best restaurants in Cape May offer top-notch flavors, unique dining experiences, and one more reason to come back for another visit, another meal, another Cape May getaway any season!

That said, some restaurants are not open year-round. So, always check before you go to a particular dining spot.

Now, what are you waiting for? Reserve your stay, and treat yourself to an unforgettable culinary adventure in this charming seaside town. Bon appétit!

7 Unforgettable Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ